Should students do music or sports?

Short Version:
This document explores the debate on whether students should prioritize music or sports, emphasizing their complementary benefits for cognitive development. 1

The Either/Or Proposition

• The document questions the necessity of forcing students to choose between music and sports, highlighting that many students initially engage in both activities. 2

• It examines factors influencing this choice, including resources, costs, and personal interests, while acknowledging the biases of educators in favor of their respective disciplines.

Comparative Benefits

• Sports are often valued for promoting teamwork, physical coordination, and health benefits, while music is recognized for enhancing cognitive skills and executive functions. 1

• Research indicates that both activities can develop similar cognitive skills, suggesting they should not be viewed as competitors but as complementary. 3

Cognitive Development Insights

• Studies show that music learning significantly enhances executive functions, such as inhibition, selective attention, and cognitive flexibility.4

• The document proposes that similar skills can be identified in sports, indicating overlapping cognitive benefits between the two fields. 5

Collaborative Potential

• It suggests that collaboration between music and sports researchers could lead to a better understanding of how both activities enhance cognitive development. 6

• The idea is to view music and sports as activities that can jointly improve executive function skills, advocating for students to engage in both for optimal learning outcomes. 1

Conclusion

• The document encourages a reevaluation of educational values to treat music and sports equally, promoting the idea that both can significantly contribute to a student's overall development. 3

________________________________________________________________________________

Teaching Brain Buzz

Learning a musical instrument requires:

1. regular practice
2. is continually challenging.
3. is a joyful activity often associated with playing in a group

If you had to transfer these requirements to sport, how would you describe them? How regular should their regular practice be and why? What would be an example of a continually challenging sports activity, and how can it be made joyful when so much of sport is based on competition?

________________________________________________________________________________

Full Version:

Should students do music or sports? I wish I were asked this question more often. Why?

Because it is a straightforward question. Which activity has more merit, benefit, or impact

on every student – music or sport?

As a music teacher, you may have already shaken your head and said, “sport”. This might not be what you personally believe, but it may be the most likely answer. With limited time in the school day to give to an activity, the benefits of sport may well outweigh the benefits of music learning.

The reasons could be social, cultural, resource-based, or historical, but in most schools, sports and music are perceived, timetabled, and esteemed very differently.

The either/or approach

The first question for me is, why does it need to be an either/or proposition? Why should we make students choose, or choose for them, between music learning and sports learning? The answer is, a lot of the time, we don’t make them decide at the start of their schooling experience. They get to do both music and sports learning as a regular part of their everyday education.

At what age does it become an either/or proposition? Or is it at what level of either sport or music?

Is the choice between music and sport influenced more by resources, cost, or availability of experienced and qualified staff, or more by underlying values and school or personal status?

Or is it all about choice – students who like music should do music, and students who like sports should do sports. And what happens to students who like music and sport?

I often find that the more questions I can pose about a given situation, the more complex that situation is. This is because I have to first acknowledge my own natural bias. I am a music teacher, and I think all students should learn music, and if they get to learn a sport, well, that is just a bonus. Now let’s flip that one around – I am a sports coach, and I think all students should learn a sport, and if they get music on the side, then that is just a bonus.

Did you nod your head at the sports coach's statement but feel a bit uncomfortable about the music teacher's statement? Should music learning be prized above sport, or is it that we, as music teachers, think and feel that the scales are heavily weighted against music learning, favouring sport?

Whenever I feel like something is very one-sided, I try to flip it around and see it from the opposite perspective. From an educational perspective, do I really think that my students should be actively discouraged from doing sport because it is less valuable to their development than music?

Can we compare the benefits of music and sport?

I am deliberately poking some pretty

painful buttons. Still, educational values and more recent research point to the idea that sport and music could benefit cognitive development through a common process and not a competitive one.

A common argument that may favour sport over music is that it develops skills like teamwork, skill development, and physical coordination, predominantly through group activity in a school context, where everyone can participate. The kicker to this argument is the benefits to cardio and respiratory health, which can be directly connected to future health for the students.

It is difficult to argue against these benefits when comparing the benefits of music learning. While the benefits of music learning can be easily mapped against the sport benefits of “teamwork, skill development and physical coordination, predominantly through group activity in a school context, where everyone can participate”, I am not sure it is as easy to map across the cardio and respiratory health benefits. It is not as straight or simple as a line between the two, and when it comes to benefits, physical health is a big one.

A new way to look at music and sport

What if music learning could benefit sport, and sport could benefit music learning? In a fascinating paper titled “Exercise, Sports, and Performance Arts Benefit Cognition via a Common Process”, Tomporowski and Pesce, academics at the Department of Kinesiology, University of Georgia, suggest that academics in the exercise, sport, and arts areas are all looking at how their activity develops cognitive skills, especially executive functions.

They found that they are discovering many of the same benefits, but they haven’t shared their research with each other to compare and strengthen their understanding of human cognitive development in general.

If researchers from different fields, such as music and sport, came together to compare, for example, how skills acquisition in sport and technique development in music impact global brain skills such as executive functions, then Tomporowski and Pesce suggest we may no longer see a competition between the two activities, but how they could potentially complement each other. This idea is not a new one. When it comes to music and language learning, discovering the overlapping neuron network that both language and music utilise has led to language and music academics working together.

Mapping music executive function development across sport

Let’s flip the description to how music learning develops executive functions across to sport. In a study of executive functions in children aged 4-12 years old, Diamond and Lee found that “Learning music involves all the aspects that account for an effective training of executive functions.”

1. Building on this research in a new paper by three researchers at Justus-Liebig-University Giessen in Germany, they found that “instrumental music training is highly likely to benefit executive function development in children.”
2. They went further but describing how music learning enhances executive functions.

Inhibition skills are required when the key or

the beat changes, and the musician needs to suppress the urge to stay in the prior key or rhythm.

Selective attention is necessary when the musician listens carefully to the sound of another player during ensemble playing. Auditory and visual working memory, as well as short-term memory, are required while remembering musical passages.

Long-term memory is involved when musical pieces are played by heart.

Cognitive flexibility is required when shifting between different musical instructions.

Could we similarly map how these skills are developed in sport?

Inhibition skills are required when the ball direction or the tempo of play changes, and the sports players need to suppress the urge to keep travelling in the prior direction or speed.

We could take the example of the overlapping neural network between music and language and apply it to music and sport in terms of executive function. When students enhance the symbol-to-sound system for reading music, they also enhance the phonological loop for reading language. The symbol to sound system and the phonological loop are the same pathways in the brain, but by using the same pathways for two quite different activities, the pathway gets wider, faster, and more reliable.

Could we look at music and sport as different activities that widen and enhance the executive function skills pathways, making it possible and preferable for every student to do music and sport to enhance their ability to learn?

Read More

Diamond, A., & Lee, K. (2011). Interventions shown to aid executive function development in children 4 to 12 years old. Science (New York, N.Y.).

Frischen, U., Schwarzer, G., & Degé, F. (2021). Music lessons enhance executive functions in 6-to 7-year-old children. Learning and Instruction.

Tomporowski, P. D., & Pesce, C. (2019). Exercise, sports, and performance arts benefit cognition via a common process. Psychological Bulletin.

More Research to Follow

Phillip Tomporowski, Professor of Kinesiology, University of Georgia